A few months back, I saw this little place called The Barn Light on Kickstarter, and sponsored their decorating project. It's a really fantastic space designed by locals Leah Fuller and Charlie Deese. The menu is pretty good, too.
We like the cafe atmosphere for lunch during the day; in the evening, I hear it's a great bar scene. Most lunch menu items are $6 and come with a little jar of house-made pickles.